Split image of two men: on the left, a man with dark hair and a beard in a white shirt, resting his head on his hand; on the right, a smiling man in a blue polo shirt.

New casting set for 'Oh, Mary!' on Broadway

Two returning cast members will play a limited run starting in September, and two new actors will join Jane Krakowski in the show from October.

Summary

James Scully and Phillip James Brannon will return to Oh Mary! on Broadway opposite Hannah Solow from September 30-October 12
Cheyenne Jackson and John-Andrew Morrison will join the cast opposite Jane Krakowski from October 14
Current cast members Jinkx Monsoon; Kumail Nanjiani; and Michael Urie play their final performances on September 28

Gillian RussoSeptember 25, 2025, 04:00

Four new cast members have been named for Oh, Mary! on Broadway, joining the company at the Lyceum Theatre later this fall.

Original cast member James Scully and former cast member Phillip James Brannon will return to the roles of Mary’s Teacher and Mary’s Husband, respectively, from September 30 to October 12. They will star opposite the previously announced Hannah Solow as Mary.

Beginning October 14, Cheyenne Jackson and Tony Award nominee John-Andrew Morrison will play Mary’s Teacher and Mary’s Husband, respectively. They will star opposite the previously announced Emmy Award nominee and Tony winner Jane Krakowski as Mary.

Current cast members Jinkx Monsoon (Mary), Kumail Nanjiani (Mary's Husband), and Michael Urie (Mary's Teacher) depart Oh, Mary! on September 28. Jenn Harris (Mary's Chaperone) and original cast member Tony [Macht] (Mary's Husband's Assistant) round out the current cast.

Oh, Mary! centers on a repressed, alcoholic version of former first lady Mary Todd Lincoln who dreams of an escape from her loveless marriage by pursuing a career in cabaret. Written and directed, respectively, by Tony Award winners Cole Escola and Sam Pinkleton, the comedy play premiered off Broadway in 2024, transferring to Broadway later that year. In 2025, the show earned five Tony nominations and was named a Pulitzer Prize for Drama finalist.

Get Oh, Mary! tickets now.

Photo credit: Cheyenne Jackson and John-Andrew Morrison. (Jackson photo by Vince Trupsin; Morrison photo by Blue Photography)

Frequently asked questions

What is Oh, Mary! about?

This dark comedy shines a spotlight on Mary Todd Lincoln and the challenges she faced in her time as First Lady — but with plenty of irreverent, silly twists. This intimate portrayal of Mary's internal struggles takes on a new character through queer comic playwright Cole Escola's unconventional perspective. Now nominated for five Tony Awards.

How long is Oh, Mary!?

The running time of Oh, Mary! is 1hr 20min. With no interval.

Where is Oh, Mary! playing?

Oh, Mary! is playing at Lyceum Theatre . The theatre is located at 149 West 45th Street (between Broadway and 6th Avenue), New York, 10036.

How much do tickets cost for Oh, Mary!?

Tickets for Oh, Mary! start at $84.

What's the age recommendation for Oh, Mary!?

The recommended age for Oh, Mary! is Ages 14+. Children under 4 are not permitted in the theater..

How do you book tickets for Oh, Mary!?

Book tickets for Oh, Mary! on New York Theatre Guide.

Is Oh, Mary! on Broadway or Off-Broadway?

Oh, Mary! is playing Broadway.

Is Oh, Mary! accessible?

Wheelchair seating in step-free Orchestra only; no elevators or escalators; accessible restroom; assisted listening and loop technology available.

Who is in the cast of Oh, Mary!?

The cast of Oh, Mary! includes Bowen Yang (as Mary Todd Lincoln), Phillip James Brannon (Mary’s Husband), Barrett Foa (as Mary's Teacher), Bianca Leigh (as Mary’s Chaperone), Tony Macht (as Mary’s Husband’s Assistant).