Aly Michalka and Cyrus Veyssi felt right at home when they joined the cast of & Juliet. Both made their Broadway debuts with the show on November 3, but they had a built-in community ready to welcome them with open arms.
Michalka, for one, texted with Alison Luff, her predecessor in the role of Anne Hathaway, Shakespeare's husband. She sets & Juliet into motion by taking the Bard's quill into her own hands and rewriting his tragic young lovers a happier ending.
"[Alison] was really helpful with letting me shadow her multiple nights and ask her questions, and she was giving me tips on little things in between," said Michalka, an actress and singer best known as one half of the pop duo Aly & AJ.
Veyssi, a viral social media creator, is part of a group chat with all the previous actors who have played May, Juliet's friend whose journey of self-discovery also leads them to love. "It's so few and far between where we see the type of representation May brings on a stage, whether it's gender fluidity or sexuality," said Veyssi. "The role of May is such a sisterhood."
That community extends to their current co-stars and production staff — Michalka pops into her onstage husband's (Corey Mach) dressing room between scenes, while Veyssi has a running joke of asking a stage manager to perform in their place — as well as to the audience. & Juliet's fun-loving story and score of '90s, '00s, and '10s pop hits has drawn in multiple generations, and the actors love getting to know them all.
"Anytime someone within the umbrella of the LGBTQIA+ community comes up to me and tells me how much this role means to them — [it's] always so beautiful," Veyssi said. "Also parents and allies of people who have someone in their life who may be going through something May is going through."
Michalka loves "seeing the kids there for the first time being like, 'I've never been to a show, but this is my favorite show,'" she said. "Being able to sign their Playbill, that's so rad. I see myself in them because I'm like, 'Oh, that was me, too.'"
You never forget your first Broadway experience, after all. Michalka and Veyssi, who perform in & Juliet through its closing on January 3, discuss their own journeys from first-time Broadway theatregoer to first time Broadway star, as well as their practical tips for today's rookie audiences.
Get & Juliet tickets now.

What was the first Broadway show you ever saw?
Aly Michalka: I want to say it was Spamalot, and it was with my sister. After that, it just became, every time we're in New York, we have to see a show.
Cyrus Veyssi: I went classic Lion King, but it was an Off-Broadway show [that made me think,] "Ooh, this is what I think I want to do": Come From Away.
Walk me through the day of your first Broadway performance. How were you feeling? How did you prepare?
Veyssi: It felt like my wedding day. I was like, "Everything that needs to be done at this point is done. I'm as prepared as can be. It just has to happen."
I was doing my first show with Makai [Hernandez], who was playing Frankie that night. Right before we went on for bows, he was like, "Pull yourself out of this and just look at the audience. They're all here for you. This is your Broadway debut."
The adrenaline is so much that I wouldn't have really been able to take that in. I think I actually screwed up my entire bow that night, but it was worth it.
Michalka: I got as much sleep as I possibly could. I slept in. I had a good breakfast my husband made me. I did a deep steam in the shower; I had a little nebulizer going. I drank a bunch of water.
We had a mini-rehearsal that day, so I was also trying to pace myself by marking things vocally so I didn't blow it all out for the show that night. I just remember [...] trying to take it all in and not feel rushed. Your nerves can get the best of you.
I actually felt quite calm, considering — and then it all just happened. It was like a whirlwind. It was crazy.

What makes & Juliet a good show for a first-time Broadway-goer?
Michalka: It's incredibly inclusive, and I mean that in many ways. You don't have to be some expert in Shakespeare lore or his work to appreciate and have fun with the show. You also don't have to be an expert on pop music to have fun and know the songs.
The story is so meaningful and deep and beautiful about accepting yourself and choosing to be true to who you really are. It's a joyful, energetic show that's going to have you — hopefully, at the end — on your feet dancing with us.
Veyssi: Looking out into the audience and seeing every different type of person you can imagine, of all different ages, is so beautiful. The common thread around making your own choices and feeling confident in those choices is something everybody can take away.
Cyrus, you come from the social media world, and Aly, you come from TV acting and music. How have your careers up to this point prepared you for your Broadway debut?
Veyssi: I did 16 years of theatre growing up. Getting out of that retirement has been so wonderfully challenging. In a way, my silly little videos online have helped me in terms of knowing how much I can do if I actually put my mind to it.
I felt so prepared, and that was such a testament to the entire team at & Juliet: the dance captains, the associate directors, the director, everyone who worked on it with me. Coming at it from the angle of, I do comedy online and my background is in comedy, being able to bring it into a show that is so funny was just so synergetic. I was very much prepared to succeed and was able to bring little -isms of Cyrus into the character of May that I have been workshopping and playing with online.
Michalka: I haven't done an acting thing in a few years because music has been such a focus for me, so it's been really fun to dive back into acting because that's obviously such a huge part of my life.
The touring world and the Broadway world feel very different to me. Obviously, you're on stage every night, but [& Juliet] is very different than an Aly & AJ show. There's a little bit more of a parameter you have to stay within. That's actually been a really great challenge, the continuity of it all. Yes, I can have some room to play here, but the lines are the lines.
And then, we don't do choreo on stage if you come to an Aly & AJ show. Getting in and learning all these dances was [...] like accessing a part of my brain from my youth, doing dance classes and being on a dance team, but it never being hyper-serious. Getting into a rehearsal space and being like, "Okay, we've got to learn this routine and we've got to sing at the same time we're doing it," was really, really fun.
