NYTG Logo

Top theatre to see in New York for Halloween

Check out these Broadway and Off-Broadway theatre shows, plus seasonal exhibits and interactive experiences, featuring all things spooky and spellbinding.

Gillian Russo
Written byGillian Russo

Spooky season is underway, and it's the perfect time to have a frightfully fun night at the theatre. Legend has it that ghosts haunt most Broadway theatres, so you could be in for a fright at any show. If you really want to get into the spirit, though, there are plenty of New York stages showcasing Halloween theatre that celebrates all things witchy, magical, and downright scary.

The whimsical magic of Harry Potter and the Cursed Child and Wicked will delight the horror-averse. The hair-raising chills and thrills of Paranormal Activity and 2:22 - A Ghost Story are perfect for scary movie lovers and crime show junkies. And shows like [Little Shop of Horrors] and The Rocky Horror Show fall somewhere in between, with a mix of funny and eerie. No matter "witch" way you celebrate Halloween, you can find a musical or play with the right tone — and that's no trick.

These shows deal with the supernatural, the criminal, and the spellbinding, and they're all on stage for the Halloween season. Plan a fun Halloween night outing to see one, or go later if you don't want the spooktacular fun to end! Browse our full lineup of Halloween shows and more at the link below.

Get tickets to Halloween events on New York Theatre Guide.

1.

Paranormal Activity

2.

The Rocky Horror Show

3.

The Lost Boys

4.

2:22 - A Ghost Story

5.

A Ghost in Your Ear

6.

Wicked

7.

Stranger Things: The First Shadow

8.

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

9.

Little Shop of Horrors

10.

Masquerade

11.

Perfect Crime

12.

Chamber Magic

13.

Speakeasy Magick

14.

Drunk Dracula

1.

Paranormal Activity

Broadway
Play
Horror
Screen to stage

The August Wilson Theatre is a bonafide haunted house all autumn long with the arrival of Paranormal Activity, a new play inspired by the hit film franchise, written by acclaimed horror playwright Levi Holloway (Grey House), and directed by Felix Barrett (Sleep No More). They scared up rave reviews with their story of a couple whose demons follow them across an ocean, haunting both their home and their hearts.

Get Paranormal Activity tickets now.

Get tickets
Paranormal Activity

2.

The Rocky Horror Show

Broadway
Musical
Comedy
Classic

If you're going to a midnight Rocky Horror screening this Halloween season, why not make it a science fiction double feature with the Broadway musical? Do the time warp with Dr. Frank-N-Furter and his fabulously feral creatures at Studio 54 — and yes, there is a late-night performance on Halloween.

Get The Rocky Horror Show tickets now.

Get tickets
The Rocky Horror Show

3.

The Lost Boys

Broadway
Musical
Fantasy
Screen to stage
Award winner

Take a bite out of this four-time Tony Award-winning musical that transports you to Santa Carla, California, a beautiful beach town and vampire haven. A newly arrived family discovers that firsthand in this show packed with pulsing rock music and jaw-dropping stagecraft.

Get The Lost Boys tickets now.

Get tickets
The Lost Boys

Unlock your 24-hour New York City itinerary

Unlock your exclusive guide, full of the best attractions, food, free events and more.

09:00

Breakfast at Liberty Bagels

Regularly named one of the city’s best bagel shops, the unassuming Liberty Bagels is the perfect spot to get a classic NYC breakfast sandwich.

10:00

Macy’s Herald Square

One of the world’s largest stores, Macy’s is a sight to behold, especially when it’s decked out for the holidays.

5.

A Ghost in Your Ear

Off-Broadway
Play
Horror
Immersive

This new "headphone horror" play from Tony Award nominee Jamie Armitage (Six) puts you in the recording booth with an actor reading a horror audiobook. But the scares soon come off the page and into real life — and, through headphones, audiences hear every bump, creak, and shriek up close.

Get A Ghost in Your Ear tickets now.

Get tickets
A Ghost in Your Ear

6.

Wicked

Broadway
Musical
Award winner
Family-friendly

What better way to ring in Halloween than with a tale of two famous witches? Wicked is the backstory behind The Wizard of Oz, with Elphaba — better known as the Wicked Witch of the West — and her friendship with Glinda the Good Witch when they were schoolmates. Wicked has been an audience favorite at the Gershwin Theatre since 2003, and it's filled with spells and gravity-defying broomstick rides. As a bonus, you'll learn the origin (according to the musical, anyway) of the famous pointy witch hat that features in many a Halloween costume.

Get Wicked tickets now.

Get tickets
Wicked

7.

Stranger Things: The First Shadow

Broadway
Play
Screen to stage
Award winner

Demogorgons, alternate dimensions, and unexplained supernatural happenings in a sleepy small town — those are the makings of a perfectly spooky show. Stranger Things: The First Shadow tells the origin story of the Netflix show's most powerful villain from the Upside Down, and you can expect a few jump scares and plenty of jaw-dropping special effects to rival Hollywood magic.

Get Stranger Things: The First Shadow tickets now.

Get tickets
Stranger Things: The First Shadow

8.

Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

Broadway
Play
Screen to stage
Page to stage
Award winner

There's no better time than Halloween for a little wizardry and witchcraft: Grab your wand and your house robes and enter the Wizarding World at Harry Potter and the Cursed Child. Years after the events of the books, Harry Potter's son Albus sets out to save the world from dark forces — which become even darker and spookier when Albus's quest messes with time.

Get Harry Potter and the Cursed Child tickets now.

Get tickets
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child

9.

Little Shop of Horrors

Off-Broadway
Musical
Award winner
Stars on stage
Screen to stage

Skid Row probably wouldn't be the best trick-or-treating spot — you might get eaten before you get any candy for yourself. Instead, enjoy the classic horror comedy Little Shop of Horrors from the safety of the audience — but still beware the snapping jaws of the flesh-eating plant Audrey II. It tasks a hapless flower shop worker, Seymour, with finding fresh meat, promising him fame and fortune if he's willing to kill for it.

Get Little Shop of Horrors tickets now.

Get tickets
Little Shop of Horrors

10.

Masquerade

Off-Broadway
Musical
Immersive

Nothing says Halloween like a costume ball. Attendees at Masquerade, an immersive reimagining of the classic musical The Phantom of the Opera, are asked to dress in formal attire and, of course, don a mask (they're provided if you don't have your own). Not to mention, the story of the titular Phantom, a mysterious, masked vocal coach who dwells in the underbelly of the Paris Opera House and becomes obsessed with its ingenue, is both enchanting and eerie.

Get Masquerade tickets now.

Get tickets
Masquerade

11.

Perfect Crime

Off-Broadway
Play
Iconic show

The longest-running play in New York is still bringing in audiences with its mystery and thrill. The psychiatrist Margaret Brent is suspected of killing her husband — until he appears alive — and things only get complicated further when the detective on the case falls for her. Even if she's innocent, foul play is afoot, but the question remains until the final gunshot: Who killed who, and can they be caught, or did they commit the perfect crime?

Get Perfect Crime tickets now.

Get tickets
Perfect Crime
Explore must-see plays

Paranormal Activity

August Wilson Theatre

Disruption

The Romulus Linney Courtyard Theatre at The Pershing Square Signature Center

Inter Alia

Music Box Theatre

Pre-Existing Condition

Greenwich House Theater

A View from the Bridge

La MaMa Experimental Theatre Club

The Play That Goes Wrong

New World Stages

The Imaginary Invalid

Todd Haimes Theatre

Oh, Mary!

Lyceum Theatre

An American Daughter

The Irene Diamond Stage at the Pershing Square Signature Center

Drunk Romeo & Juliet

The Ruby Theatre

Selected Shorts: The Five Boroughs with Cynthia Nixon

Peter Jay Sharp Theatre at Symphony Space

Perfect Crime

The Theater Center

860

Imperial Theatre

12.

Chamber Magic

Off-Broadway
Magic show
Family-friendly

In the early 20th century, the wealthy would entertain select groups of guests in intimate parlors, and magician Steve Cohen — nicknamed "The Millionaire's Magician" — recreates that experience for the public. With only a select number of seats available at each performance, audiences can expect a cozy experience where they don't just get to see time-honored (and yet utterly unbelievable) tricks — they get to be part of them.

Get Chamber Magic tickets now.

Get tickets
Chamber Magic

13.

Speakeasy Magick

Off-Broadway
Magic show
21+

You may have heard of close-up magic, but never this close up. No two shows of Speakeasy Magick are the same, as the production features a rotating lineup of celebrated magicians and illusionists. Sip on a craft cocktail in an intimate speakeasy setting, where the magicians are sitting right next to or across from you as they perform amazing acts. This show promises both tricks and treats!

Get Speakeasy Magick tickets now.

Get tickets
Speakeasy Magick

14.

Drunk Dracula

Off-Broadway
Play
Comedy
21+

The team behind the long-running Off-Broadway hit Drunk Shakespeare is sinking its teeth into another classic with Drunk Dracula. Five actors attempt to perform a zany reimagining of Bram Stoker's Dracula, except one of them takes five shots right beforehand. Everyone else has to keep the show on track no matter what the drunk actor does, and the audience even gets to join in the boozy, bloody, vampiric fun.

Check back for information on Drunk Dracula tickets on New York Theatre Guide.

Learn more
Drunk Dracula