Three people are pictured in individual portraits: a smiling man in a brown shirt, a woman in a white dress, and a man in a black leather jacket.

Jordan Fisher, Nikki M. James, Andy Karl to join 'Little Shop of Horrors' cast

The three Broadway veterans will lead the award-winning Off-Broadway musical revival at the Westside Theatre for performances beginning in March.

Summary

Jordan Fisher; Nikki M. James; and Andy Karl will star in Little Shop of Horrors off Broadway starting in March
Current stars Joshua Bassett and Joy Woods will depart March 1; Andrew Durand will depart March 8
The hit horror-comedy musical follows a flower shop worker who makes a dark deal with a flesh-eating plant

Gillian RussoFebruary 4, 2026, 05:00

Welcome to Skid Row! Jordan Fisher, Nikki M. James, and Andy Karl are the next stars of Little Shop of Horrors off Broadway at the Westside Theatre.

Fisher (Moulin Rouge! The Musical, Hadestown, Dear Evan Hansen), Tony Award winner James (The Book of Mormon, Suffs), and three-time Tony nominee Karl (Rocky, On the Twentieth Century, Groundhog Day) will lead the cast as Seymour, Audrey, and Dr. Orin Scrivello DDS, respectively. Fisher and James play their first performance March 6, while Karl joins March 10.

As previously announced, current stars Joshua Bassett (as Seymour) and Joy Woods (as Audrey) will depart the show on March 1, while Andrew Durand (as Orin) will depart March 8.

The classic horror comedy musical Little Shop of Horrors follows a shy flower shop worker named Seymour who makes a dark deal with a bloodthirsty plant for fame, fortune, and love. The current revival has run to acclaim off Broadway since 2019, winning the Drama Desk and Drama League Awards for Outstanding Revival of a Musical.

Tickets are now on sale through January 23, 2028.

Get Little Shop of Horrors tickets now.

Photo credit: Jordan Fisher, Nikki M. James, and Andy Karl. (Photos courtesy of production)

Frequently asked questions

What is Little Shop of Horrors about?

When a mild-mannered florist finds a talking, blood-drinking flower, he sees a path to success and romance. This campy horror comedy is a cult classic in person and on the silver screen, and this production won multiple Best Musical Revival awards. Get tickets to this quirky, bloody show blossoming off Broadway.

How long is Little Shop of Horrors?

The running time of Little Shop of Horrors is 2hr. Incl. 15min intermission.

Where is Little Shop of Horrors playing?

Little Shop of Horrors is playing at Westside Theatre. The theatre is located at 407 West 43rd Street, New York, 10036.

How much do tickets cost for Little Shop of Horrors?

Tickets for Little Shop of Horrors start at $56.

What's the age recommendation for Little Shop of Horrors?

The recommended age for Little Shop of Horrors is Ages 5+. Children under the age of 4 are not permitted in the theatre..

How do you book tickets for Little Shop of Horrors?

Book tickets for Little Shop of Horrors on New York Theatre Guide.

Is Little Shop of Horrors on Broadway or Off-Broadway?

Little Shop of Horrors is playing Off Broadway.

Is Little Shop of Horrors accessible?

The theatre is not wheelchair accessible. The Upstairs Theatre is on the 2nd floor (approximately 21 steps). Please be advised that where there are steps either into or within the theatre, we are unable to provide assistance.

Who is in the cast of Little Shop of Horrors?

The cast of Little Shop of Horrors includes Ethan Slater (as Seymour), Betsy Wolfe (as Audrey), Claybourne Elder (as Orin Scrivello DDS), Christian McQueen (as The Voice of Audrey II), Reg Rogers (as Mushnik), Christine Wanda (as Ronnette), Morgan Ashley Bryant (as Chiffon), Savannah Lee Birdsong (as Crystal).