Hazbin Hotel's premiere episode, “Happy Day In Hell,” opens with Erika Henningsen’s Charlie Morningstar strolls through the depraved streets, singing like a Disney princess. On Broadway, Henningsen has showcased her soaring voice as the original Cady Heron in Mean Girls: The Musical and Sandra Dee in Just In Time, opposite Jonathan Groff.

The voice role of the tempting Lucifer, prince of hell, calls for a performer like Jeremy Jordan, known for his Broadway roles as a striking newsboy in Newsies, an outlaw in Bonnie & Clyde, and a hopeless dreamer in the title roles of Floyd Collins and The Great Gatsby — to which he returns on November 10.

His onscreen musical roles include the animated Tangled: The Series, the live-action Smash, and the movie adaptation of The Last Five Years. He also performed in the play American Son and reprised the role in the film adaptation opposite Kerry Washington.

Get The Great Gatsby tickets now.

“I sing songs with the word 'gravity,'" Jessica Vosk told fans at the Hazbin Hotel Live on Broadway concert. Vosk belted out “Defying Gravity” as Elphaba in Wicked on Broadway, and as the Hazbin Hotel character of the angel Lute, Vosk’s vocals took the Internet by storm with the bloodthirsty song “Gravity.”

Before rising to fame as Elphaba, she had Broadway credits in The Bridges of Madison Country, Finding Neverland, and Fiddler on the Roof. Vosk currently stars as single mom Jersey in Alicia Keys’s semi-autobiogphical musical Hell’s Kitchen.

Get Hell's Kitchen tickets now.

Alex Brightman earned a Tony Award nomination for bringing his raspy singing voice to the title demon in Beetlejuice on Broadway, which also landed him the voice role of BJ’s cartoon iteration on Teen Titans Go!

Brightman’s demonic prowess extends to him voicing Sir Pentious and the cruel angel Adam in Hazbin Hotel. While faking virtue before the court of Heaven, Adam scribbles, “Stick it to the Man,” echoing Brightman’s breakout Tony-nominated Broadway role as Dewey Finn in School of Rock.

Starting in April 2026, Brightman stars as Josh Skinner in the Broadway transfer of Schmigadoon!, a stage adaptation of the hit Apple TV+ show.

Check back for information on Schmigadoon! tickets on New York Theatre Guide.

Krystina Alabado plays a bombshell — literally; this cyclops is known for her explosives — named Cherri Bomb, the love interest of Alex Brightman's Sir Pentious. On the Broadway stage, she played the Club Singer in American Psycho, Gretchen Wieners in Mean Girls, and an ensemble member in American Idiot, and she also appeared in U.S. tours of Spring Awakening and Evita.

Amir Talai delivered a charming “You're Never Fully Dressed Without a Smile” as the charismatic radio announcer Bert Healy in a 2018 Hollywood Bowl staging of Annie. Little did he know that Vivienne Medrano would watch a clip of his performance and cast him as the Radio Demon, Alastor, in Hazbin Hotel.

While Talai did not voice Alastor in the show's 2019 YouTube pilot (Edward Bosco and Gabriel C. Brown did, before Talai joined for the Prime Video series), the character teased, “Smile, my dear, you know you’re never fully dressed without one!”.

James Monroe Iglehart had been with Hazbin Hotel since the 2019 YouTube pilot, voicing a bar patron. Later, he ended up voicing Zestial once Hazbin Hotel debuted its official first season.

Iglehart has performed in Broadway musicals like Hamilton, Chicago, and Spamalot, and he is best known as the original Genie in Aladdin on Broadway, winning a Tony Award. (The Genie's “Friend Like Me” actually gets an animated homage in Jeremy Jordan and Amir Talai’s Hazbin Hotel duet “Hell’s Greatest Dad.”)

Iglehart got another Tony nomination for playing Louis Armstrong in A Wonderful World in 2024, and he currently stars as Lance in & Juliet on Broadway.

Christian Borle’s Vox, a television-headed demon, is like an evil Harold Hill from The Music Man. Two-time Tony-winner Borle has plenty of gravitas as the main villain of season 2.

Borle most recently appeared on Broadway as televangelist Jim Bakker in the bio-musical Tammy Faye. His debut was in the 2000 revival of Jesus Christ Superstar, before he moved onto more high-profile roles in Thoroughly Modern Millie, Spamalot, Legally Blonde, Mary Poppins, Peter and the Starcatcher, Something Rotten!, Falsettos, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, and Some Like It Hot. Broadway fans also know him as Tom Levitt on NBC's musical TV series Smash.

Lilli Cooper spews snark and sass as Velvette, one of a trio of social media queen bees, in Hazbin Hotel. On Broadway, she played another cartoon-based musical role: Sandy Cheeks in the SpongeBob SquarePants musical. She made her Broadway debut in Spring Awakening in 2006 and went on to star in Tootsie (Tony nomination), POTUS, and The Cottage.

Currently, Cooper stars as Rona Lisa Peretti in the Off-Broadway revival of The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee at New World Stages.

Get The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee tickets now.

Darren Criss is the easygoing Saint Peter, guard of the pearly gates, and extols its virtues in “Welcome to Heaven.” A founder of the Los Angeles-based StarKid Productions, Criss had a meteoric rise to theatre fame for starring in the group's A Very Potter Musical as Harry Potter. After finding greater stardom for playing Blaine in Glee, he appeared on Broadway in How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying, Hedwig and the Angry Inch, and American Buffalo.

Criss returns to his Tony Award-winning Broadway role of Oliver in Maybe Happy Ending in November 2025.

Get Maybe Happy Ending tickets now.

Alex Newell has a minor Hazbin role as Zeezi, a bestial demon of Hell. The Glee and Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist star debuted on Broadway in the 2017 revival of Once on This Island and went on to win a Tony Award for playing Lulu in Shucked, wowing audiences and critics with the song “Independently Owned.”

Newell joins Chicago on Broadway as Matron "Mama" Morton from November 17.

Get Chicago tickets now.

Alex Newell’s Shucked co-star Andrew Durand also surfaces in Hazbin Hotel as Prick, a demon cowboy with an addiction to brawls. For this two-time Drama Desk nominee, it’s not Durand’s first rodeo with the western theme. Both on and off Broadway, he played bumbling train bandit Elmer McCurdy, whose corpse went on a wild ride for 66 years before proper burial, in the musical Dead Outlaw.

Durand's other Broadway credits include Ink, Head Over Heels, War Horse, and Spring Awakening. He appears in the Encores! revival of Bat Boy: The Musical from October 29 to November 9.

Get Bat Boy: The Musical tickets now.

Kimiko Glenn is the petite cyclops Nifty: the hotel’s maid, a doltish gremlin, and a formidable killer. Glenn created the role of Dawn Pinkett in Waitress and has also made use of her spunky voice in cartoons like the musical Centaurworld, dueting with Megan Hilty. TV viewers perhaps know her best, however, as Brook Soso on Orange Is the New Black.

Fans love to hate the demon overlord Valentino while adoring the saucy voice work of Joel Perez. Both on and off Broadway, he originated the role of Mark in Fun Home.

His earliest musical theatre credit was the 2010 In the Heights national tour, and he later appeared in the 2018 NBC special Jesus Christ Superstar Live in Concert, both times in the ensemble.

Stephanie Beatriz stars as Vaggie, Charlie's serious but loyal girlfriend. So faithful is Vaggie that she seeks the aid of hell’s weapons overlord Carmilla Carmine, played by Daphne Rubin-Vega, who also played Beatriz’s romantic partner in the film adaptation of the Broadway musical In The Heights.

The Brooklyn Nine-Nine star also voiced Mirabel Madrigal in Disney’s Encanto. In addition, she starred in the thriller play 2:22 A Ghost Story in London's West End from 2021-22.

Daphne Rubin-Vega exercises her authority as Hell’s weapons overlord, Carmilla Carmine, who will stop at nothing to protect her daughters. The two-time Tony nominee created the Tony-nominated role of Mimi Marquez in Rent on Broadway in 1996 and earned her second Tony nomination for the 2004 play Anna in the Tropics.

Other Broadway credits include the revivals of Tennessee Williams's A Streetcar Named Desire, The Rocky Horror Show, and Les Misérables. She also played Daniela in the In the Heights movie musical alongside Hazbin Hotel co-star Stephanie Beatriz.

Blake Roman voices Angel Dust, Hell’s X-rated film diva who hangs at the Hazbin Hotel to pester his friends and take refuge from his abusive pimp. He sings two of the show's famous numbers: “Poison,” a pop song with bubbly beats that belie his character’s suffering, and the upbeat duet “Loser, Baby” with Keith David’s Husk.

Roman starred both on and off Broadway as Chopin, one of six members of the Comedian Harmonists, in the musical Harmony.

Patina Miller did soaring aerial stunts in her Tony-winning role as the Leading Player in the 2013 Pippin revival, and now, she's donning the wings and halo of Sera, a stubborn chief angel, in Hazbin Hotel. Miller carried over that “mother knows best” attitude from her role as the Witch in the 2022 Broadway revival of Into the Woods.

Miller first had her Tony-nominated breakthrough as Deloris Van Cartier in the 2009 West End and 2011 Broadway productions of Sister Act.

The plucky angel Emily, the younger and more conscientious sister of Patina Miller’s Sera, wouldn’t be a fan favorite without Shoba Narayan’s airy, Disney princess-like voice. Playing Disney princess Jasmine in Aladdin on Broadway showed she had the required chops.

Narayan also appeared on Broadway in Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812 opposite Josh Groban and Nessarose in Wicked, as well as Eliza Hamilton in the Hamilton national tour.

Emmy Award winner Keith David delivers his signature deep cadence as the Hazbin Hotel bartender, Husk. Husk shares a gravitas with another of David's many voice roles: the antagonistic Dr. Facilier in Disney’s The Princess and the Frog.

His Broadway roles include Oscar in The Lady from Dubuque, the Chimney Man in Jelly’s Last Jam, Judge Brack in Hedda Gabler, Floyd Barton in Seven Guitars, and Victor in Hot Feet.

Hello, Leslie! In the aptly titled season 1 episode “Hello, Rosie!”, Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer chews up her role as hell’s cannibal overlord, clad in a Dolly Levi-esque dress and grand feather hat. Rosie and her flesh-eating legion partake in a jaunty Jerry Herman throwback in “Ready For That,” a carnal homage to “Before The Parade Passes By.”

Kritzer herself had a lot of ham to chew as the Lady of the Lake in the 2023 revival of Spamalot, getting anointed with a Tony Award nomination. Opposite Hazbin Hotel co-star Alex Brightman, she starred as Delia and Miss Argentina in Beetlejuice, and her other Broadway credits include Hairspray, Legally Blonde, Elf, and Something Rotten!

Kevin Del Aguila voices a new Hazbin Hotel character in season 2. He appeared in two diametrically opposite titles on Broadway: Disney’s Frozen as Oaken (after voicing a troll in the first Frozen movie) and Some Like It Hot as Osgood Fielding III (Tony nomination), opposite Hazbin Hotel co-star Christian Borle.

Also a writer, he took home an Emmy Award for his work on Peg+Cat in 2016. His writing credits extend to the lyrics and books of musicals like Diary of a Wimpy Kid, Dog Man, Madagascar, and Altar Boyz.

In fall 2025, he appears in The Baker's Wife off Broadway.

Get The Baker's Wife tickets now.

The celestial halo fits Liz Callaway as the Speaker of God, a luminous entity from heaven. She had an early Broadway start in the original 1981 production of Merrily We Roll Along as a nightclub waitress before performing as Grizabella in Cats, her Tony-nominated role as Lizzie Fields in Baby, Lady Constance Bonacieux in The Three Musketeers, Ellen in Miss Saigon, and a performer in The Look of Love.

She has voiced many princesses in animated films: the title role of Anastasia, Odette in The Swan Princess, Jasmine in the direct-to-video Aladdin sequels The Return of Jafar and Aladdin and the King of Thieves, and Kiara in The Lion King II: Simba's Pride.

In “Hell’s Greatest Dad,” Sarah Stiles literally steals the scene — and song — from Alastor and Lucifer as the vivacious Mimzy, a flapper. Her Broadway performance in Hand to God earned her a Tony Award nomination in 2015, and she got her second one for playing Sandy Lester in Tootsie in 2019. In addition, she also doubled as Kate Monster and Lucy the Slut in Avenue Q.

Stiles has another famous cartoon credit as Spinel in Steven Universe: The Movie and Steven Universe Future, opposite Broadway titans Patti LuPone and Christine Ebersole.