Review of Encores! Me and My Girl at New York City Center

  • Our critic's rating:
    Date:
    May 14, 2018
    Review by:

    Going to a show resurrected for a week at Encores! is like visiting a museum with a special exhibit held for a limited time. It’s often an adequately diverting but distanced glimpse into the past, at best invoking nostalgia for the material and refurbishing its memory. Encores! has that mission: To bring about the older, more obscure of American musicals and present them to today’s audiences with “concert productions that remain true to each show’s era and style.”

    Is that always a good thing? At Encores!, it often doesn’t matter. We know the zeitgeist in musical theatre has been highly variable over the years, so no era of musical theatre is going to be without an audience, nor will any be received by its entire audience. Encores! productions, remaining true to their roots, allow audiences to relish what they enjoyed about them and contemplate what they didn’t.

    This is especially true for something like Me and My Girl, a “delightfully old-fashioned” 1930s London hit with its typical vintage musical kit of flashy tap numbers, easy romances, and infectious melodies. Set in 1930s London, it tells the story of Bill Snibson, a wise-cracking Cockney from the Lambeth borough of London who’s named the long-lost heir of the Harefords, a haughty aristocratic family. A stipulation to Bill’s accepting the title and estate is, of course, his becoming “fit and proper,” which members of the family such as the Duchess (Harriet Harris) and Sir John Tremayne (Chuck Cooper) attempt to bring about. When Bill’s Lambeth girlfriend, Sally (Laura Michelle Kelly), gets involved, “hilarity and chaos ensue”.

    Suffice it to say, the plot was not the reason behind the popularity of Me and My Girl. The show takes some inconsequential turns to reach its resolution, which is dully formulaic save for the nod to Pygmalion. The characters here do not sufficiently carry the show throughout; even Christian Borle, with his nonstop zingers and warm, effervescent charm was burdened by playing one of the less impressively written roles of his career. And truthfully, I wasn’t convinced by his Cockney accent. The score, possibly the most important aspect of a musical especially from that era, is largely unremarkable save for a few standouts.

    As such, Me and My Girl and its memory survive on moments. Even with Stephen Fry’s revised book, it’s the occasional highlights that become this musical, not a consistent level of entertainment throughout; moments mostly within the score, ranging from romantic and dreamy ("Me & My Girl," "Leaning On A Lamppost") to declarative ("Once You Lose Your Heart") to droll ("The Family Solicitor") to big, flashy, and show-stopping.

    Which begs mention, of course, to the famous act-one finale, “The Lambeth Walk”. It was performed with such enthusiasm and energy that the ensemble both literally and figuratively spilled off the proscenium. With that and the spoon gimmick, it’s no wonder it spawned a dance craze in the 30s. And as far as I could tell, no matter how many refrains they piled on (as far as I can tell the number exceeded ten), the audience never tired of it.

    Equally noteworthy was the second act opener, “The Sun Has Got His Hat On”. Mark Evans in the role of Gerald leads the ensemble in an excellently choreographed number that includes only the fiercest of tap routines.

    That caliber of dance, in conjunction with talented, well-cast voices, and the consistently above reproach orchestra at New York City Center, are most often what make for a memorable Broadway moment at Encores! the likes of which admittedly cannot be found anywhere else, even on Broadway. Again, the real question in putting on Encores! productions is whether those idiosyncrasies are worth the effort, or whether, like in the case of Me and My Girl, they might burden the show’s overall merit. I suppose as long as the audience leaves the theatre contentedly humming "The Lambeth Walk," with tap shoes and percussing spoons echoing through their heads, it remains a question worth exploring for future shows.

    (Photo by Joan Marcus)


    What the popular press says...

    "As the current Broadway revivals of My Fair Lady and Carousel show us, productions of even highly sophisticated works need to give us new ways of seeing them or risk irrelevance. By definition, Encores! must always walk that tightrope. Shows like Me and My Girl, cheery yet sour, make me wonder whether the upside is worth it."
    Jesse Green for New York Times

    "As is typical of its era, the show is pure fluff... Directed and choreographed by Warren Carlyle (After MidnightFinian's Rainbow), the show demonstrates Encores' amazing ability to put together polished productions, featuring elaborate musical numbers, in just a few weeks."
    Frank Scheck for Hollywood Reporter

    External links to full reviews from popular press...

    New York Times - Hollywood Reporter