In late 2018, MCC Theater moved into its own permanent home. The complex is located at West 52nd Street and 10th Avenue and consists of two theatre spaces - The Newman Mills Theater, with a seating capacity of 245, and The Susan and Ronald Frankel Theater, a 100-seat black box-style theatre.

Located in the Hell's Kitchen area of Manhattan, the MCC Theater complex cost $35 million. The public-private partnership between MCC Theater itself and the City of New York helped tremendously, with the city contributing $25.7 million to the project.