5 fun facts about 'The King's Critique' off Broadway

The new musical comedy, written by Eric Holmes and Nat Zegree and produced by Jordan Fisher, is packed with a king-sized amount of silliness.

Gillian Russo
Written byGillian Russo

Hear ye, hear ye, there's a new musical comedy in town! The King's Critique might just take the throne as one of the goofiest shows in NYC this fall. This classical-meets-contemporary, Shakespeare-esque romp follows an ambitious young woman (Taylor Iman Jones) and a playboy performer (Sky Lakota-Lynch) who team up to thwart a bumbling king's (Justin Collette) ban on female actors.

The company is serious about their silly story, which is rooted in a king-sized appreciation for theatre. "Something we're really passionate about is original material," said book writer/lyricist Eric Holmes, who co-wrote The King's Critique with composer Nat Zegree. "We love coming up with our own original stories for audiences to come in with no expectations, no preconceived notions, no 'I've read that book' or 'I've seen that movie,' and just come in for a purely new theatrical experience."

Acclaimed Broadway actor Jordan Fisher produces the musical, which plays a limited run at the Pershing Square Signature Center. Before you enter the kingdom by getting tickets, learn a bit more about The King's Critique from the cast and creatives below.

Get The King's Critique tickets now.

Summary

  • The King's Critique is a musical about an aspiring actress and a playboy performer who try to overturn a king's ban on female actors
  • The musical comedy plays at the Pershing Square Signature Center
  • The King's Critique blends a period-inspired setting and costumes with modern humor and a score inspired by iconic Broadway composers
1.

A TV writer's room sparked the inspiration for The King's Critique over a decade ago.

2.

The creative team was influenced by Shakespeare and the musical theatre greats.

3.

Audiences are seated on two sides of a runway-like stage.

4.

The costumes are over-the-top and eclectic — and some have secrets.

1.

A TV writer's room sparked the inspiration for The King's Critique over a decade ago.

In the early 2010s, Eric Holmes was an assistant on NBC's Smash under playwright and screenwriter Theresa Rebeck, the show's creator and co-executive producer who was infamously fired after season 1 amid creative differences with the team.

"I was filled with a little bit of rage over how women are treated in this industry and how all the male executive producers got away with it, and she was somehow the villain," Holmes recalled. From there, he said the idea for The King's Critique "organically came out because we were like, 'You know what? Women deserve an even bigger seat at our theatre table.'"

He and Nat Zegree wrote the show in under six months "and then threw it on a shelf," Holmes continued. In the meantime, they achieved recognition with another musical, Fly More Than You Fall, and decided to revisit The King's Critique as the themes of misogyny and inept male leadership got "upsettingly relevant culturally."

Despite the negative sides of the show's origin story, Holmes and Zegreee ultimately want The King's Critique to be a fun and positive experience. "We just wanted to write a story that was everything we absolutely love about theatre," Holmes said.

A TV writer's room sparked the inspiration for The King's Critique over a decade ago.

Photo credit: Nancy Renee Braun, Eric Holmes, Catie Davis, and the company of The King's Critique in rehearsal. (Photo by Russ Rowland)

2.

The creative team was influenced by Shakespeare and the musical theatre greats.

The King's Critique is (loosely) a period piece, so it made sense that the creators looked back — and in director Catie Davis's case, way back — to the classics. "What do we love about Shakespearean comedies?" she asked when she first came aboard. "We love the quick pace of it. We love the magical realism of it. We love characters who are cross-dressing in disguise, and everyone gets mixed up about who's who."

Holmes and Zegree looked a bit closer to the present, finding comic inspiration in 20th-century icons like Mel Brooks and Neil Simon. Their classic Broadway-style score also contains Easter eggs to a wide array of iconic theatre composers.

During the songwriting process, Holmes said he would tell Zegree, "'This should maybe sound like Kander and Ebb,' or 'This should sound like [Alan] Menken,' or 'This maybe is more [Stephen] Sondheim.'" And he would just do it.

"Not to say that he ripped any of them off," Holmes continued with a laugh. "To have the freedom to literally play in any style of musical theatre allowed the show to just be bigger and bolder than ever before." Choreographer Nancy Renee Braun said she took a similarly expansive approach dance-wise, incorporating styles from classic theatre to tap to hip-hop.

The creative team was influenced by Shakespeare and the musical theatre greats.

Photo credit: Nat Zegree and the company of The King's Critique in rehearsal. (Photo by Russ Rowland)

3.

Audiences are seated on two sides of a runway-like stage.

Shakespeare's plays aren't the only thing that influenced Davis; so did his Globe Theatre in London, at which theatregoers surround three sides of a thrust stage and the "fourth wall" between actor and audience is thin. That idea inspired the setup of The King's Critique, at which audiences face each other from two sides of a stage.

"I always find when I'm in a theatre like that, you get to watch a show, but it also feels like you're in it because you're watching the other audience watch the show, too," said Taylor Iman Jones, who stars as Josephine. "I'm excited that our show is going to have that sense of community surrounding it, literally."

And the action isn't confined to the stage, either, the actors teased. "There are some moments where actors may appear in places that are not on the stage," said Matthew Quinn, who plays the king's right-hand man Horace. "Always be aware of your surroundings because you never know where a performer may appear."

Audiences are seated on two sides of a runway-like stage.

Photo credit: A scenic design rendering for The King's Critique by Paul Tate dePoo III. (Photo by Russ Rowland)

4.

The costumes are over-the-top and eclectic — and some have secrets.

If there's one thing you can expect from The King's Critique, it's for it to be larger-than-life in every way. Jones described the costumes and dialogue as "a hodgepodge of regal and modern," while Justin Collette, who plays King Benjamin, even compared their sensibility to drag: "Big, over-the-top, hard-committed, archetypal characters delivering to the audience with your soul — that's drag, baby."

Some specific costume pieces to look out for: Sebastian's shorts (we don't know why, actor Sky Lakota-Lynch just said so) and Donna Lynne Champlin's belt stuffed with trinkets, props, and even some mid-show pick-me-ups.

"I'm going to have snacks in my belt," revealed the actress, who plays "maybe-a-witch" Cora. "Maybe you can see me passing little cookies or little Welch's Gummies." Yum!

The costumes are over-the-top and eclectic — and some have secrets.

Photo credit: Emily Rebholz with her costume design renderings for The King's Critique. (Photo by Russ Rowland)

Unlock your 24-hour New York City itinerary

Unlock your exclusive guide, full of the best attractions, food, free events and more.

09:00

Breakfast at Liberty Bagels

Regularly named one of the city’s best bagel shops, the unassuming Liberty Bagels is the perfect spot to get a classic NYC breakfast sandwich.

10:00

Macy’s Herald Square

One of the world’s largest stores, Macy’s is a sight to behold, especially when it’s decked out for the holidays.

Frequently asked questions

What is The King's Critique about?

The King's Critique is a new musical comedy about a king who silences women by declaring they cannot perform on stage.

Is The King's Critique on Broadway or Off-Broadway?

The King's Critique is playing Off Broadway.

How long is The King's Critique running?

The King's Critique currently has tickets available through 20 December 2026. Check calendar for availability.

Who is in the cast of The King's Critique?

The cast of The King's Critique includes Taylor Iman Jones (as Josephine), Sky Lakota-Lynch (as Sebastian), Justin Collette (as King Benjamin), Donna Lynne Champlin (as Cora), Matthew Patrick Quinn (as Horace), Gabi Carrubba (as Isabella).

Who directed The King's Critique?

The King's Critique is directed by Catie Davis.

Who wrote the music and lyrics for The King's Critique?

The music and lyrics for The King's Critique were written by Nat Zegree (music and lyrics) and Eric Holmes (lyrics).

Who wrote The King's Critique?

The King's Critique was written by Eric Holmes.

What's the age recommendation for The King's Critique?

The recommended age for The King's Critique is Ages 12+..

Where is The King's Critique playing?

The King's Critique is playing at The Romulus Linney Courtyard Theatre at The Pershing Square Signature Center. The theatre is located at 480 W 42nd St, New York, 10036.

How long is The King's Critique?

The running time of The King's Critique is 2hr 30min. Incl. intermission.

How do you book tickets for The King's Critique?

Book tickets for The King's Critique on New York Theatre Guide.

How much do tickets cost for The King's Critique?

Tickets for The King's Critique start at $55.