NYTG Logo
A man carries a woman in his arms on stage amidst falling confetti.

Photo credit: Hayley Atwell and Tom Hiddleston in Much Ado About Nothing on Broadway. (Photo by Andy Henderson)

'Much Ado About Nothing' Broadway review — Tom Hiddleston and Hayley Atwell make this Shakespeare revival something to see

Read our review of Much Ado About Nothing on Broadway, an NYC transfer of director Jamie Lloyd's acclaimed London revival of the Shakespearean rom-com.

Joe Dziemianowicz
Joe Dziemianowicz

In the wild and playful new Broadway production of Much Ado About Nothing, Tom Hiddleston and Hayley Atwell star as reluctant lovebirds Benedick and Beatrice, whose battle of the sexes is described as a “merry war.” Shakespeare overloads their arsenals with a steady stream of witty banter.

Director Jamie Lloyd likewise lays it on thick to set a vibe. Dance hits regularly blare during and before the show. Ushers groove in the aisles to “Pump Up the Jam” and other club beats while theatregoers settle in. On stage, actors stand ankle-deep in bubblegum-colored confetti, suggesting a Party City explosion or perhaps remains of “paper bullets,” the Bard’s poetic term for spoken grenades. When the mood is light, confetti falls like pink rain. When it’s serious, there’s no precipitation.

The revival begins with a juicy taste of Taylor Dayne’s “Tell It to My Heart,” a passionate plea for honesty. It’s fitting for a centuries-old rom-com about finding true love amid deception in every direction. So it goes for staunch bachelors Benedick and Beatrice, who awaken to the notion of marriage only after some well-intentioned trickery.

Verbally dexterous, fetching in Soutra Gilmour’s costumes, and stoked by combustible chemistry, Broadway (but not theatre) newcomer Atwell and Betrayal Tony Award nominee Hiddleston trade teasing retorts with relish.

Feisty, cool, and elegant, Atwell constantly commands attention. My favorite moment: She rises, and lip-syncs “everybody dance now” along with the famous C+C Music Factory recording that starts playing, and everyone gets down. (The energizing choreography is by Fabian Aloise.) Hiddleston, game for anything, plays the fool and the flirt, buries himself in confetti, unbuttons to flaunt a six-pack, and, scarily, leaps into a trapdoor for drama’s sake.

For the play’s other couple, Claudio (James Phoon) and Hero (Mara Huf), romance turns humiliatingly and frighteningly dark. Their sweet relationship sours disastrously due to a cruel conspiracy. Hero’s attendant, Margaret (Mason Alexander Park, a powerful vocalist), Hero’s dad Leonato (Forbes Masson), the noble Don Pedro (Gerald Kyd), and Don Pedro’s illegitimate brother, Don John (Tim Steed), are pulled into the plot in various ways.

Lloyd’s sixth Broadway show bears some of his signature hallmarks, including actors sporting visible headsets and sitting in chairs to watch others' scenes, in keeping with his minimalist approach. Lifesize cutouts of Loki and Captain Carter, the two leads’ Marvel Cinematic Universe characters, echo an Andrew Lloyd Webber replica in the director's Tony-winning Sunset Boulevard revival from 2024.

But it’s not all the same old, same old. Beyond the music and dancing, the director’s usual all-black palette gives way to pink paper shreds, lilac short shorts, and cartoonish Masked Singer-style headpieces worn during a delightfully imaginative masquerade. This old show has new tricks — and they all make this Much Ado About Nothing something to see.

3 much ado bway-1200x600-NYTG

Much Ado About Nothing summary

Written around 1600, Shakespeare’s comedy Much Ado About Nothing follows quick-witted Beatrice and Benedick, who get tricked into falling in love amid some friendly romantic intrigue. Lloyd’s production, seen last year in London, was nominated for Best Revival and Best Actor (Hiddleston). This is the play’s 16th run on Broadway.

What to expect at Much Ado About Nothing

Lloyd's revival is designed to tickle you pink before you even get inside: The exterior of the Winter Garden Theatre is painted a deep fuschia. Shakespeare purists should note that Lloyd has streamlined the play; Dogberry, who uncovers the conspiracy behind Hero’s humiliation, has been cut. The show rearranges accordingly.

Soutra Gilmour’s costumes, a pack of shimmering jumpsuits and cashmere short shorts, feel club-ready, while the bare, confetti-covered stage holds space for a giant inflatable heart. Jon Clark’s lighting lends the mood, and Ben and Max Ringham’s sound design lets each witty remark and dance beat come through loud and clear.

Much Ado About Nothing runs 2 hours and 20 minutes including an intermission.

9 much ado-1200x600-NYTG

What audiences are saying about Much Ado About Nothing

As of writing, Much Ado About Nothing has an 90% approval rating on the review aggregator Show-Score, reflecting largely favorable reactions from early theatregoers.

  • “The best show on Broadway. A celebration of life and love.” Show-Score Ashleigh 6321
  • “An amazing show. Hiddleston, Atwell, and the entire cast are phenomenal. Will be back to see it again.” - Show-Score user Ann A
  • "Version for today's youth. Played up the stuff and didn't let the acting shine." - Show-Score user Howard 6295
  • “This was a wild take on Shakespeare that was totally unexpected. It was like Baz Luhrmann’s Romeo and Juliet meets a 90s rave, in the best possible way.” - Show-Score user AC

Read more audience reviews of Much Ado About Nothing on Show-Score.

Who should see Much Ado About Nothing

  • Fans of Shakespeare will appreciate this spotlight on Much Ado. Famously, his works don’t land on Broadway with great frequency these days.
  • Theatregoers who’ve enjoyed Lloyd’s Broadway stagings of Betrayal (with Hiddleston), A Doll’s House, Sunset Boulevard, and Waiting for Godot, will be keen to see how this colorful production fits into his often monochromatic black aesthetic.
  • Fans of Hiddleston and Atwell who only know their work in the Marvel Cinematic Universe will want to see them strut on stage.
  • Fans of ’80s and ’90s pop tunes will enjoy seeing how they fit into a classic play. (“I Want It That Way,” for one, pops up here and in another Shakespeare remix: & Juliet.)

Learn more about Much Ado About Nothing on Broadway

Between Tom Hiddleston and Hayley Atwell's star power and the staging’s strong point of view, Jamie Lloyd's Much Ado About Nothing proves Shakespeare’s 425-year-old comedy is very much in the pink.

Learn more and get Much Ado About Nothing tickets on New York Theatre Guide. Much Ado About Nothing is at the Winter Garden Theatre through January 10.

Photo credit: Much Ado About Nothing on Broadway. (Photos by Andy Henderson)

Frequently asked questions

Where is Much Ado About Nothing playing?

Much Ado About Nothing is playing at Winter Garden Theatre. The theatre is located at 1634 Broadway (between 50th and 51st Street), New York, 10019.

How long is Much Ado About Nothing?

The running time of Much Ado About Nothing is 2hr 20min. Incl. intermission.

How do you book tickets for Much Ado About Nothing?

Book tickets for Much Ado About Nothing on New York Theatre Guide.

What's the age recommendation for Much Ado About Nothing?

The recommended age for Much Ado About Nothing is Ages 12+. Children under 4 years old will not be admitted..

How much do tickets cost for Much Ado About Nothing?

Tickets for Much Ado About Nothing start at $103.

What is Much Ado About Nothing about?

Much Ado About Nothing is a Shakespearean comedy about two sets of lovers and the rumors, gags, and battle of wits that keep them apart — and then bring them together.

Who wrote Much Ado About Nothing?

William Shakespeare wrote this classic comedy.

Who directs Much Ado About Nothing?

Tony winner Jamie Lloyd, known for his bold takes on revivals, directs this five-star production.

Originally published on

Subscribe to our newsletter to unlock exclusive New York theatre updates!

  • Get early access to Broadway's newest shows
  • Access to exclusive deals and promotions
  • Stay in the know about top shows and news on Broadway
  • Get updates on shows that are important to you

You can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy