

Photo credit: Andrew Durand. (Photo courtesy of production)
Andrew Durand to star in 'The Curious Case of Benjamin Button' off Broadway; complete casting announced
The Tony Award nominee will play the title role in the North American premiere of Jethro Compton and Darren Clark's musical adaptation of F. Scott Fitzgerald's book.
Summary
- The Curious Case of Benjamin Button off Broadway will star Andrew Durand in the title role alongside 14 other actor/musicians
- Off-Broadway performances run at The Public Theater from October 8 to November 15
- The musical is a love story centered on a man who ages backwards
The Public Theater has named the complete cast of The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, a new musical adaptation of the same-named book making its North American premiere. Off-Broadway performances run from October 8 to November 15, with opening night on October 21.
The cast of 15 actor/musicians is led by Tony Award nominee Andrew Durand (Dead Outlaw, The Rocky Horror Show) as Reverthi/Benjamin Button alongside Britney Coleman as Gwyns, Trevor Lindley Craft as Morlan, Brandon J. Ellis as Tewes, Katie Horner as Treth, Kelsee Kimmel as Sterenow/Elowen Keene, Sachiko Mae as Avoryow, Morgan Morse as Tonnow, Kris Saint-Louis as Lanow, Claire-Frances Sullivan as Ebron, and Matt Wolpe as Tir.
Craft, Ellis, Horner, Mae, and Sullivan are also understudies, and Jo Brook, Casey Martin Klein, Lauren Jeanne Thomas, and Spiff Wiegand are swings.
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is a love story centered on a man who ages in reverse. The musical adaptation of F. Scott Fitzgerald's novel first premiered in London's West End to acclaim. The book, lyrics, and direction are by Jethro Compton, music and lyrics are by Darren Clark, and choreography is by Chi-San Howard.
The show will also feature scenic design by Compton, costume design by Anna Kelsey, lighting design by Zoe Spurr, sound design by Luke Swaffield for Autograph Sound, and orchestrations, arrangements, and music supervision by Mark Aspinall and Clark.
Check back for information on The Curious Case of Benjamin Button tickets on New York Theatre Guide.
Frequently asked questions
How long is The Curious Case of Benjamin Button?
The running time of The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is 2hr 30min.
Where is The Curious Case of Benjamin Button playing?
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is playing at The Public Theater. The theatre is located at 425 Lafayette Street, New York, 10003.
How much do tickets cost for The Curious Case of Benjamin Button?
Tickets for The Curious Case of Benjamin Button start at $181.
What's the age recommendation for The Curious Case of Benjamin Button?
The recommended age for The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is Ages 12+..
How do you book tickets for The Curious Case of Benjamin Button?
Book tickets for The Curious Case of Benjamin Button on New York Theatre Guide.
Is The Curious Case of Benjamin Button on Broadway or Off-Broadway?
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button is playing Off Broadway.
Is The Curious Case of Benjamin Button accessible?
Accessible entrances, seating, and restrooms. Assistive Listening Devices. ASL interpreted, Open Caption and Audio Descriptions at select performances or on demand by request.
How long is The Curious Case of Benjamin Button running?
The Curious Case of Benjamin Button currently has tickets available through 20 December 2026. Check calendar for availability.
Originally published on
Latest News
- 1
Bryan Cranston, Marianne Jean-Baptiste to star in 'All My Sons' on Broadway this spring
- 2
Everything you need to know about the ‘Dirty Dancing’ Broadway musical
- 3
Myles Frost to return to 'MJ The Musical' on Broadway
- 4
Find out which Broadway shows are nominated for 2027 Grammy Awards
- 5
See new photos of 'Downstate' on Broadway
- 6
Theatre Gift Guide: Gift these Broadway shows this holiday season
- 7
The best NYC holiday shows for kids and families in 2026
- 8
Steve Carell, John C. Reilly to star in ‘The Odd Couple’ on Broadway this spring
- 9
All the times Jessica Chastain did theatre
- 10
Michelle Visage to make Broadway debut in 'Schmigadoon!'
Related articles

Subscribe to our newsletter to unlock exclusive New York theatre updates!
- Get early access to Broadway's newest shows
- Access to exclusive deals and promotions
- Stay in the know about top shows and news on Broadway
- Get updates on shows that are important to you
You can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy