NYTG Logo
Five performers stand in a line on a dark stage illuminated by bright blue spotlights and cascading pyrotechnic sparks.

Photo credit: Matthew Pomeroy, Darcy Oake, Eden Choi, Gabriella Lester, and James More in Now You See Me Live on Broadway. (Photo by Jeremy Daniel)

'Now You See Me Live' Broadway review — a mesmerizing illusion spectacle

Read our review of Now You See Me Live, a magic show inspired by the Now You See Me film franchise, playing at the Al Hirschfeld Theatre through January 3.

Kyle Turner
Kyle Turner

Now You See Me Live on Broadway is mainly cosmetically related the popular movies it ostensibly spins off from. There are branded cards used in one participatory trick; a quartet of magicians called the “four horsemen” as in the movies; and one illusion that attempts to reference the series’s quasi-Robin Hood ethos (which doesn’t exactly come to fruition).

But Broadway audiences need have no familiarity with the franchise, which could be described as Ocean’s Eleven-style heist films by way of nerdier, more preposterous Chris Angels. Now You See Me Live’s IP makeup — applied by the same producers behind the touring magic act The Illusionists — is simply a conduit for a very solid magic show, one heavy on live-camera feeds to double down on its introductory slogan: “The closer you look, the less you see.”

A cameraman could be stationed inches away from a magician and their deck of cards, and the nature of the trick would remain as mysterious as ever. Without putting too fine a point on it, Now You See Me Live includes a passing mention of the fact that all its trickery is done without AI. The incentive to look closer feels slightly weightier due to the creators' and cast's pleasure in the fact that mesmerizing illusions and spectacle can be handcrafted.

Now You See Me Live sometimes feels like a Vegas show retrofitted to a Broadway stage. It's designed to feel big in a smaller venue, it's broad and quickly paced so one act follows the next with little padding, and it features a slightly cheesy coda about remembering the formative moments in our lives. But the show, to its benefit, appears to decently anticipate a well-watched and maybe cynical New York audience, delivering legitimately impressive illusion work: Think Houdini-esque escapes, scorpion swallows, and delightful card-based sleight of hand.

The four horsemen are charming if a tad anonymous, save perhaps Matthew Pomeroy as the de facto master of ceremonies. The show's brisk pace comes at the expense of getting a deeper sense of each illusionist’s personality beyond their signature tricks: Pomeroy does switch-outs, James More disappears, Gabriella Lester fills a clear box with cash, and Darcy Oake is an escape mastermind. (A special guest, currently Eden Choi until Yollin Lee takes over on December 1, also performs at each show.) That being said, the craft on display, and the magicians' agility at working with crowds and audience members, is excellent. Now You See Me Live is a sturdy meat-and-potatoes show of commendable tricks, spectacle, and fun.

1 now you see me-1200x600-NYTG

Now You See Me Live summary

Loosely based on the Now You See Me film franchise directed by Boaz Yakin and starring Jesse Eisenberg, Isla Fisher, Woody Harrelson, and Dave Franco as magicians who pull off heists, Now You See Me Live disposes of plot in favor of being a straight-up magic show. Four main magicians — Matthew Pomeroy, James More, Gabriella Lester, and Darcy Oake — and a special guest dazzle the audience with illusions, expert showmanship, sleight of hand, and death-defying acts.

What to expect at Now You See Me Live

However often Now You See Me Live makes obligatory reference to the movies, it largely frees itself by focusing on the expert craft and skill of its magicians. The show feels decently fresh thanks to its spins and riffs on classic illusions: playing-card sleights, magically transporting personal objects, faking out the audience with a "reveal" of how a trick works. The spectacle is aided with skillful lighting work from Hugo Mercier Bosseny.

2 now you see me-1200x600-NYTG

What audiences are saying about Now You See Me Live

Now You See Me Live has an 87% audience approval rating on the review aggregator Show-Score, averaged from 145 reviews from theatregoers who shared mostly positive responses to the illusions and the pure enjoyment.

  • "Loved it, if you're fan of the movies, this is a must see. I would say though sit in the middle to the front orchestra or the mezzanine. I sat in the rear orchestra and it was difficult to take in the whole spectacle." - Show-Score user Robert C
  • "It's fun, nothing earth shattering or particularly new. Most of what they do you've probably seen variations of before, but it's still enjoyable and they're engaging performers. If you like magic shows you'll probably enjoy it." - Show-Score user MikeR
  • "Fantastic magic show....amazing. Still perplexed how they did everything. Fun, funny, joyful and entertaining." - Show-Score user Susan P
  • “Something different, energetic and fun. Good audience participation.” – Show-Score user Steven W

Read more audience reviews of Now You See Me Live on Show-Score.

Who should see Now You See Me Live

  • Fans of the Now You See Me franchise will appreciate the occasional nods to the movies, but they'll be even more impressed by the actual craft behind the illusions on display.
  • Followers of The Illusionists will enjoy the consistent inventiveness of classic card, escape, and vanishing tricks in the latest show from the same team.
  • Theatregoers who love audience participation — whether as a participant themselves or as an amused viewer — will enjoy the heavy crowd work, which always adds fun unpredictability.

Learn more about Now You See Me Live on Broadway

Now You See Me Live doesn’t reinvent the wheel for either magic shows or IP extensions on Broadway, but it offers a delightful time with fantastic feats of illusion.

Learn more and get Now You See Me Live tickets on New York Theatre Guide. Now You See Me Live is at the Al Hirschfeld Theatre through January 3.

Photo credit: Now You See Me Live on Broadway. (Photo by Jeremy Daniel)

Frequently asked questions

Is Now You See Me Live on Broadway or Off-Broadway?

Now You See Me Live is playing Broadway.

How long is Now You See Me Live running?

Now You See Me Live currently has tickets available through 3 January 2027. Check calendar for availability.

Who is in the cast of Now You See Me Live?

The cast of Now You See Me Live includes Gabriella Lester, James More, Darcy Oake, Matthew Pomeroy, and Eden Choi.

Who wrote Now You See Me Live?

Now You See Me Live was written by Tim Lawson and Adam Trent.

What's the age recommendation for Now You See Me Live?

The recommended age for Now You See Me Live is Ages 5+..

Where is Now You See Me Live playing?

Now You See Me Live is playing at Al Hirschfeld Theatre. The theatre is located at 302 West 45th Street, New York, 10036.

How long is Now You See Me Live?

The running time of Now You See Me Live is 1hr 30min. No intermission.

How do you book tickets for Now You See Me Live?

Book tickets for Now You See Me Live on New York Theatre Guide.

How much do tickets cost for Now You See Me Live?

Tickets for Now You See Me Live start at $59.

What is Now You See Me Live about?

Based on the magic of the film franchise, Now You See Me Live is a Broadway show that brings together four illusionists for a thrilling evening of stunts and tricks.

Originally published on

Subscribe to our newsletter to unlock exclusive New York theatre updates!

  • Get early access to Broadway's newest shows
  • Access to exclusive deals and promotions
  • Stay in the know about top shows and news on Broadway
  • Get updates on shows that are important to you

You can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy