NYTG Logo
Three Blue Man Group performers standing in front of a decorated fireplace, with one holding a large candy cane-shaped prop and a sign that reads “For Santa.”

Photo credit: Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise” on Broadway. (Photo by Michaelah Reynolds)

'Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise”' Broadway review — deck the halls with paint and drumming

Read our review of Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise,” the Broadway-debut show of the celebrated Blue Man Group performance troupe, running through January 3.

Summary

  • Blue Man Group shows feature three silent "Blue Men" who've come to Earth to learn human mannerisms
  • Their Broadway-debut holiday show sees the group putting an experimental, creative, and interactive spin on holiday traditions
  • The antics don't always fully reach the whole audience in the 1,500-seat Lunt-Fontanne Theatre
  • The show is recommended for Blue Man Group and experimental theatre fans, fans of holiday shows, and families with children, as BMG's shows are for all ages
Caroline Cao
Caroline Cao

“Bigger is always better,” chimes a Christmas commercial on a vintage '50s television set during Blue Man Group "A New Holiday Surprise." This isn’t always true for the Broadway-debut show of the titular silent trio, an Off-Broadway fixture for over 30 years. All at once, they want to live by and lampoon that maxim, but does dialogue-free, avant-garde curiosity translate in the 1,500-seat Lunt-Fontanne Theatre? Director Matt Ramsey — versed in donning the azure paint, banging the drums, and adopting the Blue Men's vacant stare — hasn’t solved this puzzle, but there are gumdrops of surprises.

Unpredictability is the group's game, so slight spoilers may commence from here. The show is quite a splash, literally: The Blue Men’s signature rhythmic “paint-drumming” sends paint splatters into the air. This is followed by a circus act of catching marshmallows in their mouths. One catches paint capsules and spits them onto a canvas, which he then spins like a hypnotic pinwheel. You might have to squint to see it all from a distance; one wonders why the show's live camera feeds aren’t employed to enhance payoff moments, such as one Blue Man's mouthful of marshmallows after consecutive catches.

Cameras are used when the performers wander into the audience to search for participants, at which point the show becomes taxing. I kept having to turn between the action and the circa-2000 camcorder feed to catch the Blue Men's location. In the Astor, the comedy of their audience prowl may have translated more clearly, but at the Lunt, it was like observing tedious charades from afar. It’s especially tough luck for those in the mezzanine, mostly left out of the interactivity. Amid long audience interactions, one act rakes in the laughs as the Blue Men fasten a participant into a raincoat and face shield before hurling paint at a canvas behind them.

Then there's that TV set (which is partly obstructed from the audience at house left). The old-fashioned commercials suggest an oblique arc from holiday-tradition conformity to screw-it-all anarchy. Eventually, the commercials spiral into a protracted satire on holiday too-muchness, with visual eyesores that look AI-generated. The garish slop hits as counterproductive to the show's artistic spontaneity, regardless of intention when a Blue Man rips out the TV's cord.

Because whenever they’re slapping colors onto blank canvases, the Blue Men are in their element. Just as enthralling are their percussion concerts on cans, the "drumbone" (a trombone-like PVC pipe), and giant silver bells. It’s where Richard Phillis Jr.’s sound design, otherwise a mess of prerecorded music and noise, becomes a thundering soundscape. I listened to the earthquake of percussion with rapt attention. If I could ask Santa for a DeLorean, I would time-travel to Blue Man Group’s reign at Astor Place, where I suspect I would have a merrier time.

3 blue man group broadway-1200x600-NYTG

Blue Man Group "A New Holiday Surprise" summary

Founded in 1987 by Chris Wink, Matt Goldman, and Phil Stanton, Blue Man Group is known as an NYC mainstay with other U.S. residencies and tours around the globe. After performing off Broadway from 1991 to 2025 at the Astor Place Theatre, the group now makes its Broadway debut with an experimental twist on holiday hits and the spirit of the season.

The rotating cast includes Dan Cooper, Wes Day, Mark Frankel, Alexander Pobutsky, and Pete Simpson as Blue Men. Their individual performance dates are unannounced likely to keep up the mystique. Kaylie Brooke and Anastasiya Kostromina also feature as “Spirits.”

What to expect at Blue Man Group "A New Holiday Surprise"

Throughout the 90-minute show, you will be cued to clap, stand up, raise the roof, and bat an ornament-shaped inflatable ball. (More extreme physical stunts are optional.) If you're in the orchestra, you might be a guinea pig if a Blue Man makes eye contact with you. One briefly did so with me, and I froze before someone else, to my relief, was selected.

I admittedly missed Blue Man Group's Off-Broadway run at the Astor Place Theatre; my closest contact was word-of-mouth, tourist ads, and the troupe's appearance on Arrested Development. Otherwise, "A New Holiday Surprise" was my intro. Though my introduction was rocky, it's optimal to come into Blue Man Group unknowing. You might be wondering, are these blue men aliens from an alternate universe? In short, yes. Just go with the vibes. And don’t come late, or else they will make you the butt of the joke.

Blue Man Group "A New Holiday Surprise" may affect those sensitive to strobe lights, and the production has some sightline issues. The live camera feed, grainy as it is, bridges some gaps there, but mezzanine audiences in particular may have an obstructed view.

1 blue man group broadway-1200x600-NYTG

What audiences are saying about Blue Man Group "A New Holiday Surprise"

Audience members have taken to online platforms like Reddit, TikTok, and Mezzanine to express mixed opinions on the Blue Man Group’s Broadway debut.

  • "I thought the show was absolutely fantastic. Me and my girlfriend laughed interacted and had the most incredible time I’ve had on Broadway.” - Reddit user u/Chance-Medium-9129
  • "This is an awesome, family-friendly show that makes you smile.
  • It won't change your life, but it will chang[e] your afternoon or evening. So high energy and fun." - Show-Score user Show Lore
  • "In the spirit of so many Christmas shows happening in New York, this one feels, and I mean this in a positive way, almost reluctantly Christmasy. They do a lot of great Christmasy stuff, but it’s also just a weird experimental theatre alien show [...] This is a type of show that everyone could enjoy if they are willing to lean into the spirit of play." - TikTok user u/the0tricality
  • “The Blue Man Group Holiday Surprise is a ridiculous batch of holiday silliness. The show will keep you guessing about the shenanigans they will get into. I typically don’t choose shows without dialogue but this one was still hilarious at times, weird at others, and always holiday fun. They keep you on your toes and engage with the audience quite a bit.” - My +1 at the show

Who should see Blue Man Group "A New Holiday Surprise"

  • Fans of holiday theatre should add this show to their watchlist alongside It's A Wonderful Life, A Christmas Carol, the Radio City Christmas Spectacular, and more.
  • Blue Man Group's longtime fans — and any fan of the bizarre and avant-garde — would be curious to taste their spin on holiday themes.
  • Blue Man Group is an all-ages show that's great for families. Many of the kids in my audience oohed and ahhed, and booster seats are available for the little ones.

Learn more about Blue Man Group "A New Holiday Surprise" on Broadway

Blue Man Group's interactive holiday pleasures aren’t evenly distributed in a large Broadway venue. Although it flings a refreshingly childlike, avant-garde anarchy at the Great White Way, Blue Man Group "A New Holiday Surprise" is a mixed bag of experimental goodies and burnt marshmallows.

Learn more and get Blue Man Group "A New Holiday Surprise" tickets on New York Theatre Guide. Blue Man Group "A New Holiday Surprise" is playing at Lunt-Fontanne Theatre.

Photo credit: Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise” on Broadway. (Photos by Michaelah Reynolds)

Frequently asked questions

What is Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise” about?

Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise" brings the famous trio to Broadway for the first time in a visually spectacular concert featuring a spin on holiday hits.

Is Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise” on Broadway or Off-Broadway?

Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise” is playing Broadway.

How long is Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise” running?

Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise” currently has tickets available through 3 January 2027. Check calendar for availability.

What's the age recommendation for Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise”?

The recommended age for Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise” is Ages 3+..

Where is Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise” playing?

Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise” is playing at Lunt-Fontanne Theatre. The theatre is located at 205 West 46th Street, New York, 10036.

How long is Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise”?

The running time of Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise” is 1hr 30min. No intermission.

How do you book tickets for Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise”?

Book tickets for Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise” on New York Theatre Guide.

How much do tickets cost for Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise”?

Tickets for Blue Man Group “A New Holiday Surprise” start at $50.

Originally published on

Subscribe to our newsletter to unlock exclusive New York theatre updates!

  • Get early access to Broadway's newest shows
  • Access to exclusive deals and promotions
  • Stay in the know about top shows and news on Broadway
  • Get updates on shows that are important to you

You can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy