Beautiful - The Carole King Musical

Tulis McCall
Tulis McCall

Sometimes all theatre is meant to do is make you feel good. Or in this case feel beautiful. I KNOW how cliché that sounds. Mea Culpa. Deal with it.

This is a kind of romp through the life of Carole King who, for a lot of us, is an icon. We grew up with her iconic songs about loss: It's Too Late, love: A Natural Woman; and hope: Beautiful. We were in our 20's when her first album was released. Tapestry was an album that we soaked up as if we were dry ground and King's music (with Joni Mitchell and James Taylor on backup vocals, thank you very much) were a soft spring rain. She was the real deal. Unadorned. Vulnerable and raucous. Wistful and certain. Regretful and celebratory.

Little did any of us know (or care) that this 29 year-old woman was a divorced mother of two who was so smart that she skipped to grades to arrive at college as a 16 year old and sold her first song that same year, and was short-sighted enough to get pregnant and married by the time she was 18. Turns out the man she married was Gerry Goffin who collaborated with her on the very tunes that we grew up listening to (all the hits before the Beatles that didn't come out of Motown): Up On The Roof, Take Good Care Of My Baby, Will You Love Me Tomorrow, One Fine Day. The list is ridiculously long.

This production fills in many of the pre-Tapestry details, and it works as a background to the musical numbers mostly because of Jessie Mueller - who you may remember stole the show when she appeared in On A Clear Day opposite Hary Connick, Jr. Mueller is a total pleasure and manages to bring home the essence of King but still keep her own self centered and visible. It is a nifty piece of juggling. In addition she is able to track Ms. King's vocal transition over a 13 year period. She moves from a Brooklyn teenager to a wife and mother to a woman sailing into her 30's living in Los Angeles and traveling under her own steam.

Mueller is more than ably supported by Jake Epstein (Gerry Goffin), Jeb Brown (Don Kirshner), Jarrod Specter (Barry Mann) and Anika Larsen (Cynthia Weil) who form the inner circle that surrounded and nurtured King until she set out as a solo artist. And WHO KNEW that there were women writing songs in the 50's and 60's??? Not me. As to the music - while it is a total pleasure to hear, it is so over-produced (with the exception of the intimate song writing sessions) that it will drive your sugar level up to the danger zone. The poor guys who portray The Drifters are given dance moves that are from another planet. Sorry folks - it just wasn't that way. It feels like the producers didn't trust that we would be happy seeing the old doo-wop moves that were little more than side steps and sweeping glides. Why they felt the need to tart up these numbers is a mystery.

As it is this entire production is really a concert played out on an extraordinary set by Derek McLean, lit and dressed to nines by Peter Kaczorowski and Alejo Vietti.

It's about the music, and only about the music that reaches us on a level we cannot verbalize. It's a heart and gut thing where we are at the center of our own selves. And at the center of all that music is Ms. King given over to us by the stupendous Jessie Mueller. Long may they BOTH rein.

(Photo by Joan Marcus)

"Friendly, formulaic bio-musical."
Ben Brantley for New York Times

"Too bad a great musical isn't only about the music. The book is crucial, too — and this show's connect-the-dots story line is so simplistic that the extravagantly talented King's life emerges as a mundane version of the long-suffering little woman."
Joe Dziemianowicz for New York Daily News

"The book is often heavy-handed, and Marc Bruni's production only occasionally resurrects the bubbly verve and energy of those glorious songs."
Elisabeth Vincentelli for New York Post

"If you go to "Beautiful" for the songs, you'll probably have a great time. Just don't expect anything more."
Robert Feldberg for The Record

"Fans will find "Beautiful" some kind of wonderful show."
Toma Torre for NY1

"Serves up a tasty slice of Baby Boomer heaven."
Michael Sommers for Newsroom Jersey

"This is entertaining boomer bait that elevates its by-the-numbers narrative with great songs.."
David Rooney for The Hollywood Reporter

"Whenever this bio-musical stumbles over Douglas McGrath's flat-footed book, helmer Marc Bruni rushes to the rescue with some snazzy piece of stagecraft for the sleek production numbers."
Marilyn Stasio for Variety

External links to full reviews from popular press...

New York Times - New York Daily News - New York Post - The Record - Newsroom Jersey - Hollywood Reporter - Variety

Originally published on

Subscribe to our newsletter to unlock exclusive New York theatre updates!

  • Get early access to Broadway's newest shows
  • Access to exclusive deals and promotions
  • Stay in the know about top shows and news on Broadway
  • Get updates on shows that are important to you

You can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy