Fake Birthday Tickets
New York, NY

Fake Birthday Tickets

Fake Birthday Tickets
Fake Birthday Tickets

About Fake Birthday

An evening of comedy, music, and musical comedy hosted by Caitlin Cook (Peacock, SiriusXM) and A.J. Holmes (Book of Mormon, StarKid), featuring our famous, funniest, and most fabulous friends!

Caitlin Cook is a LA-born, NYC-based, Oxford-educated, hyphen-addicted comedian, musician, writer, director, and producer. A fierce champion of mixed media and genre-bending works of art, Caitlin has carved out a space for herself smack-dab in the center of the Venn diagram between comedy, music, theater, and visual art. She has brought this approach all across the world to top-tier comedy clubs (the Comedy Cellar, the Stand, the Improv), festivals (New York Comedy Festival, SF Sketchfest, Edinburgh Fringe Festival), theaters (the Dolby Theatre, Soho Playhouse, Thalia Hall), dimly lit bar basements, strangers’s living rooms, and even a houseboat once. Caitlin has three albums out on all streaming platforms and encourages you to blast those bangers.

A.J. Holmes’ career has taken him all over the world! He is best known for playing Elder Cunningham in The Book of Mormon in the Broadway, Chicago, 1st US National Tour, West End, and Australian companies. A founding member of Team StarKid, AJ co-wrote the music and lyrics of A Very Potter Musical with Darren Criss and composed the widely-popular Twisted: The Untold Story of a Royal Vizier. His solo one-man musical Yeah, But Not Right Now has sold out the Edinburgh Fringe in 2019, the Adelaide Fringe in 2020, and the Soho Playhouse in 2021.

Run time

90 mins

Start date

November 14th, 2022

End date

December 5th, 2022



123 E 24th Street (opening fall 2023), New York, NY, United States, 10001


Asylum NYC, opened in 2017, is an underground comedy club located in Manhattan's Chelsea neighborhood. The venue is part of the national, Boston-based Improv Asylum company, which produces all types of comedy including sketch, stand-up, and improv. The venue hosts a rotating lineup of comics performing all these styles. Outside producers can also rent the space for shows like musical comedies.


Unfortunately, tickets for this event are no longer available.

Get the latest updates on Fake Birthday

Sign up to our mailing list to receive exclusive offers, new show ticket alerts and seasonal promotions. You can unsubscribe at any time.

You can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy

Subscribe to our newsletter to unlock exclusive New York theatre updates!

Special offers, reviews and release dates for the best shows in town.

You can unsubscribe at any time. Privacy Policy