New York 

Theatre Guide for reviews, tickets and listings
Off-Broadway Theatre Review

The Gospel According to Thomas Jefferson, Charles Dickens and Count Leo Tolstoy: Discord

Two Stars

Photo by Jeremy Daniel
Thom Sesma, Michael Laurence & Duane Boutté in Discord
Thom Sesma, Michael Laurence & Duane Boutté in Discord

Review by Kathleen Campion
October 6, 2017

Three guys walk into the afterlife. Not just any guys; we’re talking Thomas Jefferson, Charles Dickens, and Leo Tolstoy. Each is thrust into god’s waiting room, in the order of his demise. Each is presented in the prime of his life. Each establishes his bona fides as a leading man of his day. Then, they set about considering just why each is in the room with the others.

The discussion centers on the Christian Bible and each of these writers has standing in the discussion. Jefferson, devoted to science and the ideals of the Enlightenment, went so far as to write his own version, cutting and pasting with razor and glue. He retained the sections of the New Testament that described the philosophy of Jesus of Nazareth — but excised the miraculous and the Divine.

Tolstoy took a reductionist view as well. After converting to an ascetic morality he trimmed up much of the Russian Orthodox Bible to a simple “turn-the-other-cheek” version — five commandments, not ten.

The story teller in Dickens drove his rewrite. He wrote a short book retelling the New Testament tales of water-to-wine and blind men seeing, to indoctrinate his children into the faith. He storyboarded his bible.

Not surprisingly, these gentlemen could not agree and, sorry to report, the discussion becomes tedious. It is not banter, though there is laughter. It is not incisive, but not quite obvious either. It is honest, in that each confronts himself, filling in the human flaws that dull the finish on his statue. It’s a confessional — each of these paragons is a fraud.

At the light end of the premise, the playwright, Scott Carter, is serving up a staged version of the conversational gambit: If you could have dinner with the three greatest writers in history, whom would you choose? At the weightier end, you are forced to consider: How do you feel about the conversation by the time the port is served? Enlightened? Bilious?

I was excited to see what Scott Carter, writer and EP of Real Time With Bill Maher and an accomplished hand in all kinds of comedy, would do with a play of ideas. There are solid laugh lines (Dickens: “mankind is our bus-EE-ness”) and there are clever turns of phrase: (Tolstoy: “remove the spring from a watch and be astonished it does not tick.”). The staging is pointedly stark — the afterworld rendered in metallic furniture and prosaic etched glass panels, so the drama better be rich. It’s not thin soup so much as well short of cassoulet.

The actors inhabiting the great men have precious little breathing space. The dialogue is dense with reference and the pace is fierce. Duane Boutte’s Dickens is winning and funny, quick to offense, a dandy, flush with pretension. Michael Laurence plays his Jefferson with patrician condescension that seems just right. Thom Sesma invests his Tolstoy with gritty authenticity. Seated near the back of the cosy Cherry Lane I could smell his feet, or at least his boots, when he removed them.

Ultimately, DISCORD delivers some clever patter, some heavy lifting for the actors, and some weighty recapitulation of Jeffersons’s realism, Tolstoy’s asceticism, and Dickens’ personification of character. But when it comes to wrapping it up — the meaning of life, what’s it all about Alfie? Crickets.

(Kathleen Campion)

What the popular press said...

"Carefully laid-out, compare-and-contrast debate of a play, which is notable for its clarity and accessibility, but not so much for its sparkle."
Ben Brantley for New York Times

"Scott Carter's maddeningly dull Discord is the play a college kid writes after reading No Exit and wondering if people get—like really get—that faith is tricky."
Helen Shaw for Time Out New York

"Carter has forgotten to infuse his windy discourse with sufficient drama. As a result, it mostly feels like a clever thesis written by an ambitious graduate student."
Frank Scheck for Hollywood Reporter

External links to full reviews from popular press...

New York Times - Time Out - Hollywood Reporter

Production Details
Venue: Primary Stages at Cherry Lane Theatre
Genre: Drama
Previewed: Sep 19, 2017
Opened: Oct 1, 2017
Playwright: Scott Carter
Director: Kimberly Senior

Synopsis: This timely New York Premiere finds three of history's most famous men, all of whom wrote their own version of the gospels, debating everything from religion to literature to marriage in this new play. Thomas Jefferson (author of the Declaration of Independence), Charles Dickens (the man who brought us A Christmas Carol and Oliver Twist) and Count Leo Tolstoy (the epic Russian novelist of War & Peace fame) are trapped in a limbo where each believes their path to salvation depends on convincing the other two that they are wrong in this profound and exciting battle of truly biblical proportions.

Cast: Duane Boutté (Charles Dickens), Michael Laurence (Thomas Jefferson), and Thom Sesma (Leo Tolstoy)
Click here for latest cast & more details...




Tickets New York 

Top of page
Review Index
Return to previous page

DISCLAIMER : Every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained in these pages. We accept no responsibility for any errors.

© Copyright: all rights reserved