New York Theatre Guide for reviews, tickets and listings
Off-Broadway Theatre Review

Buyer & Cellar

Fibe Stars

Photo credit: Sandra Coudert
Michael Urie (Alex)
Michael Urie (Alex)
More production photos

Note. The reviews are from when Buyer & Cellar played at Rattlestick Playwrights - unless stated.. The show is now playing at the Barrow Street Theatre, where it transferred on 18 Jun 2013, and opened on 24 Jun 2013.

(Review by Tulis McCall)
Review of the transfer run now playing at the Barrow Street Theatre

Itís the writing. Itís the writing. Itís the writing.

There is the writing of this hilarious and poignant play and there is the writing of the book My Passion For Design, by Barbra Streisand, on which this play was based. Well, not based actually Ė perhaps it is more accurate to say this play sprouted from Ms. Streisandís book.

Streisand has a compound, you see, in Malibu. To this compound she added a barn, complete with a mill wheel and chickens: A sort of New England like structure that appeared to be transported in. But the real magic was in the cellar where Streisand has created a street of old timey shops to house her collection of, well, everything. Dolls, antiques, gifts etc all set up with precision and attention to detail that is excruciating.

As explained by Michael Urie, this entire evening is a piece of fiction. He cannot say that often enough. It is based on an encounter that Jonathan Tolins, the author, had with Ms. Streisand who attended one of his other productions and offered him a Kit Kat bar beforehand. He refused and has regretted it ever since. This is his regret turned into homage.

After reading about Streisandís cellar village Tolins decided that a mini mall needed an employee and who better than an out of work actor. Enter Alex More (Urie). And we are off. More takes us on a tour not only of Streisandís home but, more importantly, his relationship with his partner Barry who nearly achieves lift-off when speaking of Streisand. Barry is so close he can taste it and is driven nearly insane that his boyfriend is actually in the same microbial neighborhood as Ms. Streisand.

And soon enough Alex is in the real presence of her Royalness. The encounter is unexpected and brilliant, as are the following sightings. The rich text is enhanced by Urieís delicate performance under the direction of Stephen Brackett. They made the very excellent choice to stay away from a direct imitation of Streisand. With so many men out in the world going to great lengths to imitate her, this team chose instead to give us a fluid image. We get the essence of her the way we might detect a scent on someone passing by. While Barry and Alex are fully formed, Streisand remains elusive.

This is a story in a story in a story. The story of Alex and Barry runs parallel with the story of Alex and Streisand. That the two are connected is what gives this play a connection to reality. That connection is not only important to us; it is ultimately the refuge for Alex.

This is one of those productions that remind you why you love theatre. Because it is live magic performed without a net. This is something that could NEVER be made into a film. It is too pure for that. This is an evening of rabbits being pulled out of a hat. You watch it being done over and over, and yet you cannot put your finger on exactly happens. You only know that it does and you are one of the people fortunate enough to see it.

Get out of the heat and into this theatre for a show you will adore for a multitude of reasons. Bravo indeed.

What the popular press said...

"A featherweight but irresistible play."
David Rooney for New York Times

"Between the script and Urie, the play makes the sale."
Joe Dziemianowicz for New York Daily News

"Fantastically funny."
Elisabeth Vincentelli for New York Post

"A mean, funny and finally moving one-man show."
Jeremy Gerard for Bloomberg
Review of the transfer run now playing at the Barrow Street Theatre

"Inventive, witty, and pretty wonderful."
Erik Haagensen for Back Stage

"Audaciously original, and I should add, hilariously clever and consummately performed."
Roma Torre for NY1
Review of the transfer run now playing at the Barrow Street Theatre

"The show is never less than amusing, but more shallow than it needs to be to keep us laughing."
Marilyn Stasio for Variety
Review of the transfer run now playing at the Barrow Street Theatre

External links to full reviews from popular press...

New York Times - New York Daily News - New York Post - Bloomberg - Back Stage - NY1 - Variety

Production Details
Venue Barrow Steet Theatre
Genre: Comedy
Previewed: 18 Jun 2013
Opened: 24 Jun 2013
Closed: 27 Jul 2014
Cast: Barrett Foa
at Rattlestick Playwrights
Previewed: 20 Mar 2013
Opened: 03 Apr 2013
Closed: 12 May 2013
Genre: comedy
Playwright: Jonathan Tolins
Director: Stephen Brackett
Cast: Michael Urie (Alex).
Synopsis: Alex More has a story to tell. A struggling actor in L.A., Alex takes a job working in the Malibu basement of a beloved megastar. One day, the Lady Herself comes downstairs to play. It feels like real bonding in the basement, but will their relationship ever make it upstairs?


Buy Broadway Tickets New York Hotels
Top of page
Review Index
Return to previous page

DISCLAIMER : Every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained in these pages. We accept no responsibility for any errors.

© Copyright: all rights reserved